Voting Systems and the Right to Vote
Why Voting Systems Matter
In a representative democracy, citizens choose people to make decisions for them. But the way votes are counted can change who wins. The same votes, counted under different rules, can produce a very different Parliament. The UK uses first-past-the-post (FPTP) for Westminster general elections. Some other UK elections, such as those for the Scottish Parliament and the Northern Ireland Assembly, use forms of proportional representation. In this lesson you will learn how FPTP works, who can and cannot vote, how often elections happen, the debate about votes at 16, and how FPTP compares with proportional systems.
How First-Past-the-Post Works
For general elections, the UK is divided into 650 constituencies. Each constituency elects one MP. Voters put a single cross next to the candidate they prefer. The candidate with the most votes wins the seat. They do not need more than half of the votes — they just need more than anyone else. Winning this way is called a plurality. The party that wins the most seats across the country usually forms the government.
Westminster general elections use first-past-the-post across 650 constituencies. Each constituency elects one MP, and the candidate with the most votes wins — a plurality, not necessarily a majority.
Who Can and Cannot Vote?
The group of people who have the right to vote is called the franchise. To vote in a UK general election, you must be registered to vote and aged 18 or over on polling day. You must also be a British citizen, an Irish citizen, or a qualifying Commonwealth citizen living in the UK. British citizens living abroad can also register to vote.
Some people cannot vote in general elections. People under 18 are excluded. Members of the House of Lords cannot vote, because they already sit in Parliament. Convicted prisoners serving a sentence in prison cannot vote. People found guilty of certain electoral offences, such as fraud, lose the right for a period of time. Most EU citizens living in the UK cannot vote in general elections, although Irish citizens can. By convention, the monarch does not vote, so that the Crown stays politically neutral.
To vote in a UK general election you must be registered, aged 18 or over, and a British, Irish or qualifying Commonwealth citizen. Under-18s, members of the House of Lords and convicted prisoners serving a prison sentence cannot vote.
How Often Are General Elections Held?
Under the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, a general election must be held at least every five years. Parliament automatically ends five years after it first met, unless it has been ended earlier. Ending a Parliament so that an election can take place is called dissolution. The prime minister can ask the monarch to dissolve Parliament early. This means elections can come sooner than five years — for example, early general elections were held in 2017 and 2019.
Extending the Franchise: Votes at 16
The franchise has changed many times. Women gained equal voting rights with men in 1928. In 1969, the voting age was lowered from 21 to 18. Today, the debate is about whether 16 and 17-year-olds should be able to vote in general elections.
Some parts of the UK have already made this change. In Scotland, 16 and 17-year-olds voted in the 2014 independence referendum. They can now vote in Scottish Parliament and Scottish local elections. In Wales, 16 and 17-year-olds can vote in Senedd and Welsh local elections. In 2025 the UK government announced plans to lower the voting age to 16 for general elections too. This would need a new law passed by Parliament. As a result, a 16-year-old in Cardiff can vote for the Senedd but, under current law, not for an MP.
Supporters argue that 16-year-olds can already work, pay tax and join the armed forces with permission, so they should have a say in how they are governed. Decisions about education, jobs and the environment affect young people for longer than anyone else. Supporters also point to Scotland and Wales, where 16 and 17-year-olds already vote, and argue that voting young can build a lifelong habit of taking part.
Opponents argue that 18 is the age at which people are treated as adults for most legal purposes, so the voting age should match. They worry that some 16-year-olds may not yet have enough experience or knowledge of politics. Others argue that it would be inconsistent to let 16-year-olds vote while they cannot do other adult things, such as buy alcohol. Both sides make serious points, and this remains a contested political question.
Strengths and Weaknesses of FPTP
Supporters say FPTP has clear strengths. It is simple: voters mark one cross, and results are counted quickly. It usually produces a single-party majority government that can carry out its manifesto. Each MP represents one area, so there is a strong link between voters and their MP. When FPTP did not produce a majority in 2010, the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats formed a coalition government that lasted until 2015 — but this is unusual under FPTP.
Critics point to serious weaknesses. A party can win a large majority of seats with well under half of the national vote. Votes for losing candidates do not help elect anyone, so many votes are “wasted”. In a safe seat, the result is so predictable that some voters feel there is little point voting. Smaller parties whose support is spread thinly across the country can win very few seats, even with lots of votes.
Proportional Representation
Proportional representation (PR) describes voting systems where a party’s share of seats roughly matches its share of votes. If a party wins about a fifth of the votes, it should win about a fifth of the seats. Several PR systems are already used in the UK.
The Additional Member System (AMS) is used for the Scottish Parliament. Voters cast two votes: one for a constituency representative and one for a party on a regional list. The list seats top up parties that did badly in the constituencies. The Single Transferable Vote (STV) is used for Northern Ireland Assembly elections and Scottish local elections. Voters rank candidates 1, 2, 3 and so on, and votes are transferred according to those preferences until all the seats are filled.
The Additional Member System is used for the Scottish Parliament. The Single Transferable Vote is used for the Northern Ireland Assembly. Both are more proportional than first-past-the-post, which is used for Westminster.
Comparing FPTP and PR
Supporters of PR argue it is fairer, because seats reflect how people actually voted. Fewer votes are wasted, smaller parties can win seats, and more people may feel their vote counts. Critics argue PR often leads to coalitions, which can be slower to make decisions. Voters may not know which parties will end up governing until after deals are made. Systems like STV are also harder to count and understand. There is no agreement in the UK about which system is best, and different parties take different positions.
In 2011, a UK-wide referendum asked whether to replace FPTP for Westminster with the Alternative Vote (AV). Under AV, voters rank candidates, and the lowest-placed candidate is knocked out in rounds until one has more than half the votes. Voters rejected the change: 67.9% voted to keep FPTP and 32.1% voted for AV. Supporters of reform point out that AV is not a fully proportional system, so the result did not settle the wider debate about PR.
Writing a list of FPTP strengths, then a list of PR strengths, and stopping describes the systems but does not evaluate them. A stronger answer weighs them against each other using a clear test, such as fairness or stable government. For example: “FPTP is more likely to give a stable majority, but it does this by giving some parties far more seats than their vote share deserves.” Then decide which test matters more, and say why.