Taxation and Government Spending
Why Does Government Collect Tax?
Schools, hospitals, roads, the police and welfare benefits all cost money. The government raises most of this money through taxation. In the UK, central government collects most taxes. Local councils also raise some money through council tax and business rates, which you met when you studied local government. Without tax, the government could not provide the services citizens rely on from birth to old age.
Direct and Indirect Taxes
Central government raises two broad kinds of tax. A direct tax is paid straight to the government by the person or business it is charged on. Income tax is the best-known example: people pay it on what they earn. National Insurance is also taken from earnings and helps to fund state benefits and the NHS. Corporation tax is a direct tax that businesses pay on their profits. Income tax is designed so that people who earn more pay more.
An indirect tax is added to the price of something you buy. The shop collects it and passes it on to the government. Value Added Tax (VAT) is charged on most goods and services. There are also duties on items such as fuel, alcohol and tobacco. Indirect taxes are easy to collect, but critics point out that everyone pays the same tax on the same item, whatever their income. This means indirect taxes take a bigger share of a poorer person’s income than a richer person’s.
Direct taxes (such as income tax, National Insurance and corporation tax) are paid straight to the government on income or profits. Indirect taxes (such as VAT and fuel duty) are added to the price of goods and services and collected by the seller.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer
The Chancellor of the Exchequer is the senior cabinet minister in charge of the government’s money. The Chancellor runs HM Treasury, the department that oversees public finances. Each year the Chancellor presents the Budget to Parliament. The Budget sets out the government’s plans for income (the taxes it will raise), expenditure (what it will spend) and debts (how much it will borrow and repay). MPs debate the Budget, and tax changes must be approved by Parliament. This is an important check: the government cannot simply raise taxes without Parliament’s consent.
The Chancellor also makes decisions about the allocation of public funding. Government departments such as health, education and defence all want more money. The Treasury decides how the total is shared out. Every choice has an opportunity cost: money spent on one service cannot be spent on another. If the Chancellor gives more to hospitals, something else may get less, taxes may rise, or borrowing may increase.
The Chancellor of the Exchequer budgets for income, expenditure and debts, manages financial risks and decides how public funding is allocated. The Chancellor presents the Budget to Parliament, which must approve tax changes.
When the government spends more than it raises in tax in one year, it runs a budget deficit. It covers the gap by borrowing, mainly by selling government bonds called gilts. Year after year, this borrowing adds up to the national debt. The government must pay interest on this debt every year. Money spent on interest is money that cannot be spent on schools or hospitals.
Part of the Chancellor’s job is managing risk. A recession can cut tax income because fewer people are working, while spending on benefits goes up at the same time. Emergencies such as a pandemic or a natural disaster can demand sudden extra spending. Interest rates can rise, making debt more expensive. To plan for these risks, the Chancellor uses forecasts from the independent Office for Budget Responsibility and tries to leave some room in the budget for shocks.
There are different views on debt. Some argue that borrowing to invest in things like roads, schools and research is sensible because it can help the economy grow. Others argue that high debt is risky and unfair on future generations, who will have to pay it back. Both views appear in real political debate.
Debates About Public Services
The specification asks you to understand different views about how governments and other service providers pay for welfare, health, care of the elderly and education. Services are provided by central government, local councils, and sometimes charities, voluntary groups and private companies. Because money is limited, people disagree about who should pay, how much, and who should benefit. These disagreements reflect different values about the role of the state and individual responsibility.
One viewpoint is that welfare should be generous and, where possible, universal — given to everyone in a group, such as all pensioners. Supporters say this means no one in need slips through the gaps, it avoids stigma, and it reduces poverty and inequality.
A contrasting viewpoint is that welfare should be means-tested, so help goes only to people whose income or savings are below a set level. Supporters say this targets limited money at those who need it most, keeps costs down for taxpayers, and protects incentives to work. Critics reply that means-testing is complicated and some eligible people never claim.
Health. The NHS is free at the point of use and paid for mainly through taxation and National Insurance. Some argue this fair, collective model should be protected even if taxes must rise. Others argue that rising demand means the funding model needs reform or greater efficiency.
Care of the elderly. An ageing population means more people need health care and social care. Unlike the NHS, social care is not always free: people with savings may have to pay towards it. Some say care should be funded by everyone through tax, like the NHS. Others say people who can afford it should contribute, so public money goes further. Different parties have proposed different solutions.
Education. Schools are funded by the state. There is debate about university tuition: should students pay through loans, because they gain from a degree, or should taxpayers pay, because society benefits from a skilled workforce?
To spend more on any public service, a government has three main options: raise more in tax, borrow more (adding to the national debt), or spend less on something else. Debates about welfare, health, elderly care and education are really debates about which of these trade-offs is fairest.