Criminal and Civil Law
Two Types of Law
Not every legal problem involves a crime. A burglar breaking into a house and a neighbour who refuses to pay back money they owe are both legal problems. However, they are dealt with in very different ways. The burglary falls under criminal law. The unpaid money falls under civil law. Knowing which is which helps you understand how the justice system in England and Wales works in everyday life.
The specification gives each type of law a clear purpose. Criminal law is used to protect the public from harm, such as when crimes are committed against a person or property. Civil law is used to settle civil disputes, such as debt, personal injury and family matters.
The Purpose of Criminal Law
Criminal law exists to protect the public. It covers two broad kinds of harm. Crimes against a person include assault, where someone is physically attacked. Crimes against property include theft, burglary and criminal damage. A crime is seen as an offence against society as a whole, not just against the victim. That is why the state brings the case, not the victim personally. This process is called the prosecution. The person accused of the crime is the defendant.
In a criminal trial, guilt must be proved beyond reasonable doubt. This is a high standard. It protects people from being wrongly convicted, because the consequences can be serious. If the defendant is found guilty, the court can punish them. Punishments include a fine, a community sentence or prison. You will look at sentencing in more detail later in this unit.
The Purpose of Civil Law
Civil law deals with disputes between private parties. These can be individuals, businesses or other organisations. The person who starts the case is the claimant. The person or organisation they bring the case against is the defendant. The claimant must show, on the balance of probabilities, that the defendant is responsible. This simply means it is more likely than not that the claim is true.
The specification names three types of civil dispute you should know:
- Debt — for example, a customer who has not paid a bill, or a landlord who keeps a tenant’s deposit without good reason.
- Personal injury — for example, a person who is hurt because a driver was careless and who wants compensation for pain and lost wages.
- Family matters — for example, divorce, or disagreements about where children will live after parents separate.
If the claimant wins, the defendant is found liable, not “guilty”. The aim is not punishment but a remedy. The court may award damages, which is money to make up for the loss. It may also grant an injunction, which orders someone to stop a certain action. The goal is to put the injured person back, as far as possible, in the position they were in before the harm happened.
In criminal law, the state prosecutes a defendant and must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The outcome is punishment, such as a fine or prison. In civil law, a claimant brings a case against a defendant and must win on the balance of probabilities. The outcome is a remedy, such as damages or an injunction.
Many students assume that any harmful or unfair act must be a crime. This is not true. Failing to pay a debt is unfair, but it is usually a civil matter, not a crime. The police do not arrest someone for owing money. Instead, the person who is owed the money can make a civil claim.
Sometimes one incident can lead to both types of case. Imagine a driver who causes a crash while driving dangerously and injures a pedestrian. The state could prosecute the driver for a driving offence. Separately, the injured pedestrian could bring a civil claim for personal injury. The two cases are different processes, with different standards of proof and different outcomes.
Why the Difference Matters
Earlier in this unit you saw that we need laws to protect the public, to settle disputes and to achieve justice. Criminal and civil law share out these jobs. Criminal law protects the public by punishing harmful behaviour. Civil law settles disputes and gives people a way to get things put right. Each system also uses its own words. Criminal cases involve a prosecution, a verdict of guilty or not guilty, and a sentence. Civil cases involve a claim, a finding of liable or not liable, and a remedy.
To sort a case, ask two questions. First, has someone harmed a person or property in a way society punishes? If so, it is criminal. Second, is this a disagreement between two private parties where one wants something put right? If so, it is civil. A stolen bike is criminal, because it is a crime against property. A shop refusing to refund money it owes is civil, because it is a debt.
Family matters show why civil law is not about blame or punishment. When parents separate and cannot agree on arrangements for their children, nobody has committed a crime. A court helps settle the dispute in a fair way. This shows how civil law helps people live together when relationships break down.
Use the right words for each system. Criminal: prosecution, defendant, guilty or not guilty, sentence. Civil: claimant, defendant, liable or not liable, remedy such as damages or an injunction. The word “defendant” is used in both.