People in the Justice System
Who Works in the Justice System?
The justice system in England and Wales depends on two groups of people. The first group is trained professionals: police officers, judges and lawyers. The second group is ordinary citizens who give up their time to help justice work. These citizens are often called lay people. Remember that England and Wales have a different legal system from Scotland and Northern Ireland, so this lesson describes England and Wales only.
The Police
The police keep the public safe. They try to prevent crime, investigate crimes that have happened and gather evidence. They can arrest people suspected of an offence. They can also stop and search people, and in many cases search property. These are strong powers, so the law controls how they are used.
Before stopping and searching someone, an officer usually needs reasonable grounds. This means a real reason to suspect the person is carrying something like a weapon or stolen goods. A hunch, or a person’s appearance alone, is not enough. This rule protects citizens from unfair treatment and links to the principle of equality before the law.
The police prevent and investigate crime, gather evidence and arrest suspects. Their powers, such as stop and search, are limited by the law. Officers usually need reasonable grounds before they can search someone.
Your Rights on Arrest
Being arrested is serious, but citizens keep important rights. The specification names three rights you must know:
- The right to know the reason for the arrest. The police must tell you why you are being arrested.
- The right to inform someone of the arrest. You can ask for a family member or friend to be told where you are.
- The right to see a solicitor. You can get legal advice from a qualified lawyer, and this advice is free at the police station.
These rights put the fundamental principles of law into practice. Knowing the reason for arrest means you can respond to the accusation. Telling someone means you cannot simply disappear into custody. Seeing a solicitor gives you access to justice, because most people do not know the law well enough to defend themselves.
Anyone arrested has the right to know the reason for their arrest, the right to inform someone that they have been arrested, and the right to see a solicitor.
An arrest only means the police suspect someone. It is not a verdict. Under the presumption of innocence, a person is treated as innocent until they are proved guilty in court. This is exactly why the rights on arrest matter: they protect people who may have done nothing wrong while the police investigate.
Judges and Magistrates
Judges are legally qualified professionals. They manage trials, make sure they are run fairly and rule on points of law. In the Crown Court, the judge decides the sentence if a defendant is found guilty. In civil cases, a judge usually decides the outcome. Judges are appointed on merit through the independent Judicial Appointments Commission. This protects judicial independence, so the government of the day cannot control court decisions.
Magistrates are lay people. They are volunteers from the local community, not legally qualified judges. They receive training and a court legal adviser guides them on the law. Magistrates usually sit as a bench of two or three. They hear more than nine in ten criminal cases, mostly less serious ones, in the magistrates’ court. There is no jury there, so magistrates decide both the verdict and the sentence. Serious cases are sent to the Crown Court.
Supporters say lay magistrates bring local knowledge and common sense. Justice is delivered by the community, not just a legal elite. Because magistrates are volunteers, the system is also cheaper to run than one using paid judges for every case.
Critics argue that magistrates lack legal expertise and may not be consistent from one area to another. Some also worry that magistrates may not reflect the full diversity of the communities they serve. Both sides raise genuine points about fairness and quality of justice.
Legal Representatives
Legal representatives help citizens understand and use the law. A solicitor advises clients, prepares their case and can speak for them in lower courts. A barrister is a specialist advocate who argues cases in court, especially in the Crown Court. Barristers are usually instructed by solicitors. People who cannot afford a lawyer may qualify for legal aid. Without legal representation, access to justice would depend on how much money you have.
Citizens’ Roles in the Legal System
Jurors. A jury is made up of twelve citizens chosen at random from the electoral register. Jurors must be aged 18 to 75. Jury service is a civic duty, and you cannot usually refuse without a good reason. Jurors listen to the prosecution and the defence, then decide if the defendant is guilty or not guilty. The judge prefers a unanimous verdict but can accept a majority of ten to two.
Magistrates. As you have seen, magistrates are volunteers who hear cases in the magistrates’ court. Special constables. A special constable is a volunteer police officer. Special constables wear uniform, work alongside regular officers and hold the same powers.
Tribunal members. A tribunal settles specialist disputes, such as problems at work. A tribunal panel often includes a legally qualified chair plus members without legal training who have relevant experience. Their real-world knowledge helps the panel reach fair decisions.
Citizens take part in the legal system as jurors, magistrates, special constables and members of a tribunal hearing. Each role lets ordinary people help deliver justice.
In a Crown Court trial, the jury decides whether the defendant is guilty. The judge manages the trial, explains the law to the jury and passes sentence after a guilty verdict. Make sure you keep these two roles separate in your answers.
Why Citizen Involvement Matters
Involving ordinary citizens keeps the justice system connected to the public. It means people are judged by members of their own community, not only by officials. It also spreads responsibility for justice across society. Critics point out that lay people lack legal training, so professionals remain essential. A balanced view recognises that the system works best when trained experts and active citizens work together.