StudyVault
Home Unit Overview Revision Techniques Previous Lesson Next Lesson

Back to Home

Page tint:
0:00 / 0:00

Courts, Tribunals and Youth Justice

Two Kinds of Court

The justice system in England and Wales has two main branches. Criminal courts deal with people accused of breaking the law, such as theft or assault. Civil courts settle disputes between people or organisations, such as unpaid debts or injuries caused by someone else’s carelessness. Each branch has its own courts, and each court handles different types of case. Knowing which court does what is the key to this lesson.

Criminal Courts: The Magistrates’ Court

Most adult criminal cases start in the magistrates’ court. A magistrate is an ordinary member of the community who has been trained to hear cases. Magistrates are volunteers, not lawyers. They usually sit in a group of two or three, called a bench, with a legal adviser to help them on points of law. Some cases are heard instead by a district judge, who is a paid legal professional and sits alone. There is no jury. The magistrates decide whether the defendant is guilty and, if so, choose the sentence. They deal with less serious crimes, called summary offences, such as shoplifting, minor assaults and many driving offences. Their sentencing powers are limited, so they cannot give the longest prison sentences.

Criminal Courts: The Crown Court

The Crown Court deals with the most serious crimes, called indictable offences. Examples include murder, rape and robbery. A trial here is led by a professional judge, but the verdict is decided by a jury of twelve ordinary citizens. The judge runs the trial, explains the law to the jury and passes sentence if the defendant is found guilty. The Crown Court can give much tougher sentences than the magistrates’ court, including life imprisonment. It is more formal: judges and barristers often wear wigs and gowns.

Key Fact

The magistrates’ court hears less serious (summary) offences. Magistrates or a district judge decide guilt and sentence, with no jury. The Crown Court hears serious (indictable) offences. A judge runs the trial and a jury of twelve decides the verdict.

Some crimes sit in the middle. These “either way” offences, such as some thefts, can be tried in either court. The magistrates first decide whether the case is too serious for them. If they think it is suitable, the defendant can still choose a jury trial in the Crown Court. Some defendants prefer this because they want their guilt decided by fellow citizens.

Magistrates can also send a case to the Crown Court for sentencing if they feel their own powers are not strong enough. The Crown Court also hears appeals from people who think the magistrates’ court got their case wrong.

Civil Courts: County Court and High Court

Civil cases are not about punishment. They are about putting things right, usually by ordering one side to pay money or to stop doing something. The county court handles most everyday civil disputes. These include unpaid debts, personal injury claims, problems with landlords and broken contracts. Smaller claims are handled in a simpler way, so ordinary people can bring a case without a lawyer.

The High Court deals with civil cases that are high-value, complicated or legally important. It also hears judicial review cases, where judges check whether a public body, such as a government department, has acted lawfully. This links to the idea of checks and balances on government power.

Key Fact

The county court hears most everyday civil claims, such as debt and personal injury. The High Court hears high-value, complex or important civil cases, including judicial review of public bodies.

Tribunals and Mediation

Not every dispute needs a court. A tribunal is a specialist body that settles disputes in one area. For example, an employment tribunal hears disputes between workers and employers, such as unfair dismissal or discrimination at work. Tribunals are usually less formal, quicker and cheaper than courts. The panel often includes people with expert knowledge of that area, not just lawyers.

Another option is mediation. A trained, neutral mediator helps both sides talk through the problem and reach their own agreement. The mediator does not decide who is right. Mediation is often used for neighbour disputes, family break-ups and disagreements between businesses. It can save money and stress, and it can help people keep a working relationship afterwards.

Many students think mediation works like a court, with someone giving a ruling. It does not. In a court or tribunal, a judge or panel makes a decision that both sides must follow. In mediation, the two sides make the decision themselves. The mediator only guides the conversation. If mediation fails, the dispute can still go to a court or tribunal. A weakness is that it only works if both sides are willing to compromise.

Youth Justice

In England and Wales, the age of criminal responsibility is 10. This means a child aged 10 or over can be charged with a crime. The youth justice system deals with offenders aged 10 to 17. Its main aim is to prevent offending and reoffending. It treats young people differently from adults because they are still developing and have a better chance of changing their behaviour. Local youth justice teams work with young offenders, their families and schools.

Most cases involving young people are heard in a youth court. Youth courts differ from adult courts in several ways. Cases are heard by specially trained magistrates or a district judge, and there is no jury. The setting is less formal: there are no wigs or gowns, and the young person is usually called by their first name. The public is not allowed in, and the media usually cannot name the young person. A parent or guardian must normally attend if the young person is under 16. Very serious cases, such as murder, can still be sent to the Crown Court.

Key Fact

Youth courts hear cases for 10 to 17-year-olds. They are less formal than adult courts, have no jury, keep the public out and usually protect the young person’s identity. The aim is to prevent reoffending, not just to punish.

One viewpoint is that a separate youth system is fair and sensible. Young people are still maturing and can be influenced by others. Protecting their identity gives them a chance of a fresh start, and a focus on changing behaviour may reduce crime in the long run. This fits with the idea that children have special rights, such as those in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.

A contrasting viewpoint is that victims deserve to see justice done in public, whatever the offender’s age. Some people argue that an age of criminal responsibility of 10 is too low, while others argue that serious crimes should be treated the same regardless of age. Both views raise real questions about fairness, protecting the public and helping young people change.

Why This Matters for Citizens

The courts are where the principles of law become real. Ordinary citizens play a part as magistrates and jurors, and tribunals and mediation give people cheaper ways to resolve problems. The youth justice system shows how society balances punishment with giving young people a second chance. These ideas link closely to debates about sentencing and crime in the next lesson.

Exam question

AI feedback
This is a guide, not an exam mark. If your teacher marks it differently, go with your teacher.

Next lesson Back to unit
Explainer