Conflict, Human Rights and NGOs
Rights and Responsibilities When Conflict Breaks Out
War puts human rights under huge pressure. Homes are destroyed, families flee and food, water and medicine run short. Ordinary people who play no part in the fighting are often the ones who suffer most. This lesson looks at how the world tries to protect people in conflict, who does that work, and how the UK responds when international disagreements turn into crises.
In conflict, rights and responsibilities pull against each other. A government has a responsibility to defend its people, which can mean using force. But civilians still have a right to life, to safety and to be treated humanely. Soldiers have the right to defend themselves, but also a responsibility to follow the rules of war. People fleeing danger have a right to seek safety in another country, while the countries receiving them must balance this against their own resources and security. These tensions have no easy answers, which is why they make good evaluation questions.
In conflict situations, rights must be balanced against responsibilities. Governments must defend their people but protect civilians; soldiers may fight but must follow the rules of war; people fleeing danger have a right to seek safety elsewhere.
International Humanitarian Law: The Rules of War
International humanitarian law is the set of rules that applies during armed conflict. It is sometimes called the law of war or the rules of war. Its purpose is not to stop wars from happening. Instead, it limits how wars are fought, so that the harm to civilians and to people who can no longer fight is kept as small as possible.
The core treaties are the Geneva Conventions. The first was agreed in 1864, and the four main conventions in use today were agreed in 1949. Key rules include: telling the difference between fighters and civilians, and never deliberately targeting civilians; caring for wounded and sick soldiers, whichever side they are on; treating prisoners of war humanely; and protecting doctors, nurses, hospitals and aid workers. Separate treaties ban certain weapons altogether, such as chemical weapons and anti-personnel landmines.
International humanitarian law limits how wars are fought rather than banning war. The Geneva Conventions (the main four agreed in 1949) protect civilians, wounded and sick soldiers, prisoners of war, and medical staff.
Many students think the rules of war exist to stop wars. They do not. International humanitarian law accepts that conflicts happen and sets limits on behaviour once fighting has started. It also applies to every side equally — it does not matter who started the conflict. A soldier who mistreats a prisoner breaks the law, whether their side is attacking or defending. Keep this clear in your answers: the law protects people, it does not decide who is right.
Making the Rules Count
Rules only matter if breaking them has consequences. Serious breaches, such as deliberately killing civilians, are called war crimes. The International Criminal Court, set up in 2002 in The Hague, can put individuals on trial for war crimes. The International Committee of the Red Cross works in conflict zones to remind all sides of their duties, visit prisoners of war and provide neutral help. However, enforcement is difficult. Some powerful states have not joined the International Criminal Court, and those accused may never be arrested.
The Role of NGOs
A non-governmental organisation (NGO) is a group that works independently of governments, often as a charity. Because they are not tied to one country, NGOs can sometimes reach people that governments cannot. Their work falls into two main types.
The first is humanitarian relief: emergency help to protect people at risk right now. Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders) sends medical teams into war zones and disaster areas. The Red Cross and Red Crescent movement provides first aid, shelter and help tracing missing family members. Relief keeps people alive in the short term.
The second is development: long-term support that helps communities stand on their own feet. Oxfam works on both relief and development, including clean water and support for farmers. WaterAid focuses on safe water and sanitation. Development work aims to tackle the causes of poverty, which can also reduce the risk of future conflict. Other NGOs, such as Amnesty International, campaign and report on human rights abuses to put pressure on governments.
NGOs provide relief (emergency help to protect people at risk, e.g. Médecins Sans Frontières) and support development (long-term improvements, e.g. WaterAid). Some, like Amnesty International, campaign against human rights abuses.
Supporters argue: NGOs are independent and neutral, so all sides may let them in. They can act quickly, they have specialist skills, and they keep public attention on suffering that governments might ignore.
Critics argue: NGOs depend on donations, so funding can dry up. Aid workers may be blocked or attacked, and supplies can be stolen by armed groups. Relief treats the symptoms of conflict but cannot end the fighting itself — only political solutions can do that.
How the UK Responds: Mediation, Sanctions or Force
When an international disagreement or conflict arises, the UK can use three main methods. Mediation means using diplomacy to bring the sides together to agree a peaceful solution. Sanctions put pressure on a country or group, for example by banning trade in certain goods. Force means using the armed forces, usually as a last resort and often alongside allies or the United Nations.
Case study: Sierra Leone. Sierra Leone, in West Africa, suffered a civil war from 1991. A rebel group called the Revolutionary United Front (RUF) carried out terrible abuses against civilians. The RUF funded its fighting partly by selling diamonds. The United Nations responded with sanctions, including an arms embargo and a ban on buying diamonds that did not have an official government certificate. Peace talks also took place, and a UN peacekeeping mission was sent in.
In May 2000, the peace process was collapsing. The RUF threatened the capital, Freetown, and hundreds of UN peacekeepers were taken hostage. The UK sent troops in Operation Palliser. At first the aim was to evacuate British and other foreign citizens, but British forces also helped secure Freetown and its airport, supporting the UN mission. The UK later helped train Sierra Leone’s own army. The war was declared over in 2002. This case shows sanctions, diplomacy and force being used together.
For: Force can protect civilians quickly when mediation and sanctions have failed. In Sierra Leone, supporters argue British action helped stop the RUF taking Freetown and gave the peace process a second chance.
Against: Force risks the lives of soldiers and civilians, costs a great deal and can drag a country into long conflicts. Critics argue the UK should act only with UN backing and should prefer mediation and sanctions, which carry less risk of loss of life.