StudyVault
Home Unit Overview Revision Techniques Previous Lesson Next Lesson

Back to Home

Page tint:
0:00 / 0:00

Viewpoints, Goals and Planning

This lesson explains what stages 3 and 4 of a citizenship action involve and how to write about them. The issue, viewpoints, goals and plan your team actually used will be your own. For exam answers, use your notes and records from your own action, not the examples in this lesson.

Where This Lesson Fits

Your citizenship action follows six stages set out in the specification. By the time you reach stage 3, your team has already identified an issue and carried out secondary and primary research. This lesson covers the next two stages: stage 3, representing your own and different points of view, and stage 4, planning the action. Together they turn your research into a clear decision about what to do, who to reach and how you will know if it worked.

Remember that a team must have at least two people. In the exam, the section on your own citizenship action is one question worth 24 marks (15% of the qualification). It is divided into short- and medium-response parts that test how you apply your knowledge and understanding, and it ends with a 12-mark task that also tests how well you analyse and evaluate. Every answer must be based on the citizenship action you actually carried out, so keep clear records of your issue, research, plan and outcome. The decisions you make in stages 3 and 4 become the evidence you write about.

Stage 3: Representing Different Points of View

Stage 3 asks you to show that you understand the issue. That includes your own opinions and the views and perspectives of different people. A citizenship issue rarely has only one side. Imagine a team worried that young people in their area have few safe places to meet. Young people, nearby residents, local councillors and the police might all see that issue differently. Each group has its own interests and concerns.

Next, you review the evidence and research you gathered and the different viewpoints people expressed. The key question is why some evidence or viewpoints may be more compelling evidence than others. Useful tests include: Did your team collect it yourselves through primary research, or does it come from a trustworthy secondary source? How many people does it represent? Might the person giving the view have a reason to be one-sided? Asking these questions shows you are judging evidence, not just collecting it.

Key Fact

Stage 3 has three parts: show understanding of the issue, including your own opinions and the views of different people; review the evidence and viewpoints and consider why some are more compelling or persuasive than others; then make the case for what your team thinks should happen.

Making the Case

The last part of stage 3 is to consider the different viewpoints and make the case for what your team thinks should happen. Making the case is more than stating an opinion. A strong case has three parts: your team’s position, the evidence that supports it, and a response to the strongest view against it. This is exactly the kind of reasoned, substantiated judgement that the evaluation skill rewards across the whole course.

Many students think stage 3 is complete once they have written down what different people said. It is not. The specification asks you to review the viewpoints and consider why some are more persuasive than others, then use that judgement to decide what should happen. A list of opinions with no judgement shows understanding, but it does not show evaluation. Always add a “because”: which view convinced your team most, and why?

Stage 4: Planning the Action

Stage 4 begins with three decisions. First, identify who the action will target: your target audience. Second, set goals for the proposed activity. Third, identify success criteria for judging success.

Your target might be a decision-maker who has the power to change things, such as a local councillor or a headteacher. Or it might be a wider group whose awareness you want to raise, such as other students or local residents. The choice matters, because the target shapes the method. A letter suits a decision-maker; an assembly or social media campaign suits a large audience.

Goals and success criteria are not the same thing. A goal says what you want to happen, for example “raise awareness of the issue among Year 9 students.” A success criterion says what evidence will show it happened, for example “a survey after our assembly shows more Year 9 students know about the issue than before.” Criteria you can measure make your evaluation in stage 6 far easier and more convincing.

Key Fact

Planning starts by identifying who the action will target, setting goals for the activity and identifying criteria for judging success. Without success criteria agreed in advance, a team has no fair way to judge whether its action worked.

Building a Clear Plan

Next, your team considers possible methods and approaches and forms a clear action plan. The specification says this must include key steps, sequence and priorities, and must take account of the time and resources available. Look ahead to stage 5: your action will either advocate for the issue through an event, meeting or campaign, or create a social benefit through a social action project, social enterprise or other community action. Choose the method that best fits your goal and target.

Think of the three planning words like this. Key steps are the tasks that must be done. Sequence is the order they must happen in — you cannot run a survey after the event it is meant to measure. Priorities are what matters most if time or resources run short.

Finally, allocate roles and tasks to each team member. Anticipate possible difficulties and decide how you would overcome them. Then set up a simple system for recording decision-making and progress, such as dated meeting notes or a shared log. This record is valuable: it gives you specific detail to use when you explain and evaluate your action later.

Key Fact

A clear plan includes key steps, sequence and priorities, takes account of time and resources, allocates roles and tasks to each team member, anticipates difficulties and how to overcome them, and records decision-making and progress.

Return to the imaginary team worried about safe places for young people to meet. In stage 3, they find that their own survey of students is the most compelling evidence because they collected it themselves and it represents many young people. They make the case that a space should be made available. In stage 4, they choose local councillors as their target, because councillors can make decisions for the area. Their goal is to persuade councillors to discuss the issue. Their success criterion is getting a meeting or a written reply. Their plan sets out the steps in order, gives each member a role, and notes a back-up if councillors do not respond.

The specification asks teams to be realistic about whether their aims will be wholly or partly met. What matters is that you can explain your planning decisions and later judge how well they worked, using evidence from your own action. A plan that went wrong, explained honestly against clear success criteria, can be written about very well.

Linking Stages 3 and 4

Stages 3 and 4 connect directly. The case you make in stage 3 decides what your action is trying to achieve. The goals and success criteria you set in stage 4 decide how you will judge it. When you write about your action, show this link: explain which viewpoint convinced your team, how that shaped your target and goals, and how your plan was designed to meet them.

Exam question

AI feedback
This is a guide, not an exam mark. If your teacher marks it differently, go with your teacher.

Next lesson Back to unit
Explainer