StudyVault
Home Unit Overview Revision Techniques Previous Lesson Next Lesson

Back to Home

Page tint:
0:00 / 0:00

Evaluating Impact and Writing About Your Action

This lesson teaches the general skills of evaluating a citizenship action and writing about it in the exam. The examples here are made up to show the method. In the exam you must write only about the action you and your team actually carried out, so use your own goals, evidence and notes from your teacher.

Why Evaluation Matters

A citizenship action does not end when your event finishes or your campaign closes. The final stage is to look back and judge what happened. This matters in the exam. One section of your exam is worth 24 marks, or 15% of the whole qualification. Every answer in it must be based on the action you took part in.

The specification asks you to do three things at this final stage. First, consider how and why your action did, or didn’t, achieve its intended effect, judging its success against your goals. Second, assess how well the method you selected worked in practice and what you might do differently next time. Third, consider the impact the action had on your own citizenship learning, including what you learned from any mistakes.

Key Fact

Evaluating your action has three parts: judging success against your goals, assessing how well your method worked and what you would change, and explaining the impact on your own citizenship learning, including learning from mistakes.

Judging Success Against Your Goals

When you planned your action, you identified who the action would target. You also set goals and chose success criteria. Evaluation means going back to those goals and criteria. You cannot judge success fairly if you never said what success would look like.

Imagine a team whose goal was to persuade the local council to put more bins near a park. Their success criteria might be collecting a set number of petition signatures and getting a reply from a councillor. In their evaluation, they would say which criteria they met, which they missed, and — most importantly — why. Perhaps they met the signature target because they used social media, but got no reply because they wrote to the wrong person.

This is the difference between describing and evaluating. Describing says “we made posters and held a meeting.” Critical evaluation says “our meeting partly met our goal, because twenty parents attended, but none of them were from the group we were targeting.” Always link a judgement to evidence and a reason.

This is not true. The specification states that students will not be penalised where an action did not go as planned. It also says teams should be realistic about whether their aims will be wholly or only partly met. An action that went wrong can give you excellent material, because you can explain exactly why it fell short and what you would change. Marks come from the quality of your evaluation, not from how successful the action was.

How Well Did Your Method Work?

Your team chose one of two broad approaches. Either you organised an event, meeting or campaign to advocate for your issue by informing, influencing and persuading a target audience. Or you organised a social action project, social enterprise or other community action to create a benefit for others, such as resources, support, advice or a service. To evaluate your method, ask: did it reach the people we targeted? Did we have enough time and resources? Did each team member’s role work, and did we overcome the difficulties we expected?

You should also judge your research. Secondary research uses existing sources, such as official reports, news stories or statistics. Primary research is evidence your team gathered itself, such as surveys, interviews or observations. Ask whether your research questions were the right ones and whether your evidence was strong enough to guide your choice of action.

Key Fact

A strong “what I would do differently” point is specific and fixes a weakness you have already identified. “Plan better” is too vague. “Contact the council officer responsible for parks in week one, not week four” is specific and linked to a clear problem.

Your Own Citizenship Learning

The last part of evaluation is about you. Taking citizenship action requires a range of skills: research and enquiry, interpreting evidence, planning, collaboration, problem solving, advocacy, campaigning and evaluation. Think about which of these you developed and give a moment from your action that shows it. Mistakes count too. Explaining what a mistake taught you shows real reflection.

Your action should also relate to the citizenship concepts you studied in the course. For example, if your team contacted the local council, you may now understand the difference between elected councillors and the officers employed to run services. Linking your action to course content like this shows you can apply citizenship knowledge to your own action (AO2), not just describe an event.

Writing About Your Action in the Exam

The own-action section is one question split into several parts. The shorter and medium-length parts test how you apply knowledge to your own action. The final part is a 12-mark task. It asks you to analyse and evaluate, so you need a reasoned argument and a clear, supported judgement.

The own-action section of the exam is one question worth 24 marks (15% of the qualification). It is divided into short- and medium-response parts targeting AO2 and ends with a 12-mark task targeting AO2 and AO3 (analysing and evaluating evidence to make judgements). Every answer must be based on the citizenship action you actually carried out, so keep clear records of your issue, research, plan and outcome.

Key Fact

The own-action section is worth 24 marks (15% of the qualification), and every answer must come from the action you actually took part in.

Use a simple chain for each paragraph: state a goal, give evidence of what happened, judge how far the goal was met, then explain why. Cover your method and your own learning in the same way. Finish with an overall judgement, such as “partly successful,” and the single most important reason for it.

Compare two answers. A weak answer says: “We held an assembly and it went well.” A stronger answer says: “Our assembly met our awareness goal, because our follow-up survey showed most pupils now knew about the issue. However, it did not change behaviour, so next time we would add a pledge card to turn awareness into action.” The second answer uses evidence, judges against a goal and suggests a specific change.

Exam question

AI feedback
This is a guide, not an exam mark. If your teacher marks it differently, go with your teacher.

Next lesson Back to unit
Explainer