Attitudes and Action on Climate Change
Why Do People Disagree About Climate Change?
Scientists agree that the climate is warming. However, people do not all agree on how serious the problem is, who caused it, or who should pay to fix it. Geographers study the different views, values and attitudes held by each stakeholder. A stakeholder can be a person, a business, a pressure group or a whole country.
Views on climate change range widely. Some people see it as an emergency that needs urgent action now. Others accept it is happening but think action should be slow so that jobs and living standards are protected. A small number doubt that humans play any part at all. The natural greenhouse effect keeps the Earth warm enough for life. Human activities such as burning fossil fuels have made it stronger (the enhanced greenhouse effect), and this is the main cause of the warming seen since the Industrial Revolution.
Views on climate change depend on values (what people think matters most) and attitudes (how they feel about acting). The same evidence can lead different stakeholders to very different conclusions about what should be done.
What Shapes a Stakeholder’s View?
Several factors shape how people see climate change. Where they live matters: people on low-lying coasts or in drought-prone regions feel the risks directly. Their job and income matter: workers in fossil fuel industries may fear losing their livelihoods. A country’s level of development matters: poorer countries want to grow their economies, just as richer countries did in the past. Age can matter too, because young people will live with the consequences for longest.
Low-lying island nations. Sea level rise and stronger storms threaten their homes, farmland and fresh water. They usually call for the fastest and deepest cuts in emissions.
Low Income Countries (LICs). They have released little of the world’s greenhouse gas but often suffer most. Many argue that richer countries caused the problem and should help pay for poorer countries to cope.
Newly Industrialised Countries (NICs). Rapid industrial growth has raised their emissions. They want to reduce poverty through growth, so they may resist limits that slow development.
Fossil fuel companies and their workers. Cutting coal, oil and gas use threatens profits and jobs. Some companies are investing in cleaner energy, while others push for slower change.
Global Initiatives to Reduce the Impact
Greenhouse gases mix freely in the atmosphere. Carbon dioxide released in one country warms the whole planet. This means no single country can solve climate change alone, so nations have tried to agree shared targets.
The Kyoto Protocol (1997) was the first major international agreement to set legally binding emission targets. It focused on richer, industrialised countries. The United States signed it but never ratified it, and fast-growing countries such as China had no binding targets, which limited its effect.
The Paris Agreement (2015) brought together almost every country in the world. It aims to keep global warming well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels and to try to limit it to 1.5°C. Each country sets its own pledge to cut emissions and is expected to update it every five years.
Responses to climate change fall into two groups. Mitigation tackles the cause by cutting emissions. Adaptation helps people cope with the effects, such as building flood defences.
Strengths. Global agreements create a shared goal. They put pressure on every country to act and let nations compare progress. Including almost all countries, as Paris does, means the biggest emitters are involved.
Weaknesses. Countries can leave agreements or miss their pledges. Under Paris, countries choose their own targets, so pledges may not add up to enough. Disagreements between richer and poorer countries about fairness can slow progress.
What Can Individuals Do?
Every person has a carbon footprint. Individuals can reduce theirs through everyday choices:
- Walking, cycling or using public transport instead of driving.
- Saving energy at home, for example by insulating lofts and turning down heating.
- Reducing, reusing and recycling, so less waste goes to landfill.
- Flying less and choosing locally produced food.
Individual action matters because millions of small changes add up. It also shows politicians what voters care about. However, one person’s choices make little difference on their own, and some options cost money that not everyone has. This is why action by governments is also needed.
What Can Local Government Do?
Local councils control many services that affect emissions. They can build cycle lanes, run park and ride schemes and support bus services. They organise recycling collections and can plant trees. Through planning decisions they can encourage energy-efficient homes and renewable energy schemes. Councils act because their areas face local risks such as flooding, and because cleaner transport also improves air quality for residents.
What Can National UK Government Do?
National government can pass laws that affect the whole country. The Climate Change Act 2008 made the UK the first country to set a legally binding long-term target to cut emissions. In 2019 the target was strengthened to reach net zero by 2050.
To meet this, the government supports renewable energy such as offshore wind farms, replacing coal-fired power stations. It can also give grants for home insulation and electric vehicles, and use taxes to discourage polluting activities.
Why does the UK government act? It has signed international agreements such as Paris. It wants to reduce the risk of floods, droughts and heatwaves in the UK. It also sees economic benefits, because new green industries create jobs. Some people argue the UK is too small an emitter to matter, while others say richer countries should lead by example.
Action on climate change happens at different scales. Individuals change their own behaviour. Local government shapes transport, waste and planning in its area. National government sets laws and targets, such as net zero by 2050.
Who Should Act?
Most geographers conclude that no single group can solve climate change. Global agreements set the direction, national laws turn targets into rules, councils deliver local changes and individuals make daily choices. The challenge is that each stakeholder has different values, so agreeing who should do most, and who should pay, remains controversial.