Trade and Aid: Reducing Inequality
Trade: Who Wins and Who Loses?
Every country buys and sells goods and services. The things a country buys from abroad are its imports. The things it sells abroad are its exports. Trade can spread wealth around the world. But the pattern of trade can also widen the gap between rich and poor countries. That is one reason for uneven development.
High income countries like the UK mostly export high-value manufactured goods and services. Many low income countries export primary products, which earn less and whose prices rise and fall sharply. Ethiopia is a good example. Its best-known exports are coffee, oilseeds and cut flowers. Its imports include fuel, machinery and vehicles. When a country sells cheap raw goods and buys expensive finished goods, it can end up with a trade deficit.
Trade causes uneven development when poorer countries depend on low-value primary products with unstable prices, while richer countries sell high-value manufactured goods and services. Ethiopia exports coffee and flowers but imports fuel and machinery.
Tariffs and Trade Blocs
A tariff is a tax on imports. Tariffs protect a country’s own businesses, but they make it harder for poorer countries to sell abroad. Some richer countries charge higher tariffs on processed goods, such as roasted coffee, than on raw goods, such as coffee beans. This is called tariff escalation. It discourages producer countries from adding value to their crops at home, so most of the profit is made elsewhere.
A trade bloc is a group of countries that trade freely with each other. Members gain easy access to each other’s markets, but countries outside the bloc can be shut out. The UK was part of the European Union trade bloc until it left in 2020. It now negotiates its own trade deals, including with India. Ethiopia has joined the African Continental Free Trade Area, which aims to cut tariffs between African countries.
India is a newly industrialised country with a growing trade partnership with the UK. India sells clothing, textiles and medicines to the UK. It also sells services, especially IT services from cities such as Bengaluru. The UK sells India machinery and drinks such as Scotch whisky, which has long faced high Indian tariffs.
This shows trade can reduce global inequality. By selling services and manufactured goods, India has moved away from relying on raw materials. But the benefits are uneven within India. Fast-growing cities gain far more than many rural areas, so trade can widen gaps inside a country even as it narrows them between countries.
Fair Trade: Ethiopian Coffee
Fair trade tries to make trade fairer for producers. Farmers in a fair trade scheme are guaranteed a minimum price for their crop, even if world prices fall. They also receive an extra payment called a premium. Ethiopia is often called the home of Arabica coffee, and much of it is grown by small farmers who join together in cooperatives.
The cooperative members decide together how to spend the premium. It can pay for schools, clean water supplies or coffee-processing equipment. Processing equipment matters because it lets farmers add value to their beans before selling them, keeping more of the profit in Ethiopia.
Fair trade gives farmers a more stable income, so they can plan ahead and send children to school. But it only reaches farmers who join certified schemes, and certification costs money. Shoppers in countries like the UK must also be willing to pay a little more. Fair trade helps the farmers it reaches, but on its own it cannot change tariffs or trade bloc rules.
Trade can reduce inequality through fair trade, lower tariffs and adding value to products at home. It can increase inequality through tariff escalation, trade blocs that shut out poorer countries and reliance on primary products.
Aid: Helping Now and Helping Later
Aid is help given to a country. The country or organisation that gives it is the donor. The country that receives it is the recipient. You need to know the advantages of aid for both sides, using one long-term programme and one emergency response.
Long-term aid: the Productive Safety Net Programme
Long-term development aid builds a better future. Ethiopia’s Productive Safety Net Programme (PSNP) began in 2005. It is run by the Ethiopian government and funded with help from donors, including the UK. Families in rural areas that often run short of food receive cash or food. In return, adults who can work help build community projects such as hillside terraces, water ponds, roads and tree planting. People who cannot work, such as the elderly, receive direct support.
For the recipient, families get regular support, so they do not have to sell their animals or take children out of school in a bad year. The terraces and ponds reduce soil erosion and store water, so communities cope better with drought. For the UK as donor, preventing hunger is cheaper than paying for emergencies later. It also builds a stable, long-term partnership with an important country in East Africa.
Short-term aid: the 2015–16 drought
Short-term emergency aid saves lives in a crisis. In 2015–16, an El Niño event weakened the rains in Ethiopia. Harvests failed and livestock died. Millions of people needed food aid. The Ethiopian government and international donors, including the UK, supplied emergency food, water, nutrition treatment for malnourished children and feed for animals.
For the recipient, emergency aid stopped a drought turning into a famine and kept children alive. For the UK as donor, it met a humanitarian duty that the public supports, and it helped stop the crisis spreading into wider hunger, conflict or forced migration.
Long-term and emergency aid are not rivals. During the 2015–16 drought, the safety net already reached many rural families, so help could be stepped up quickly through a system that already existed. Emergency aid then filled the gaps. Long-term aid reduces how often emergencies happen; emergency aid deals with the shocks that still get through.
Ethiopia’s PSNP (since 2005) is long-term aid: cash or food for work on terraces, ponds and roads. The 2015–16 drought response was emergency aid: food, water and nutrition after El Niño weakened the rains. Both benefit donor and recipient.
Trade and aid both aim to reduce inequality, but in different ways. Fairer trade lets countries earn their way up. Aid fills the gap when earning is not enough. The strongest answers explain how they can work side by side.