Managing Global Cities
Why Global Cities Need Managing
In the last lesson you saw that fast urbanisation brings serious challenges: poverty and deprivation, poor-quality housing, crowded transport and waste that piles up. Cities cannot simply wait for these problems to fix themselves. Governments, councils, charities and residents use strategies that aim to reduce inequality and improve the lives of the people who live there.
The strategies look very different in our two cities. Mumbai is in India, a newly industrialised country (NIC). Its biggest task is giving people safe homes, clean water and a way to reach jobs. London is in a high income country (HIC). Its focus is on making the city sustainable, which means cleaner, greener and fairer for people now and in the future. You must use the same two cities you studied for growth and ways of life.
Mumbai: Four Types of Strategy
Dharavi is one of the largest slums in Asia. It sits close to Mumbai’s business districts, on land that is now very valuable. Homes are small and crowded, and many lack private toilets or piped water. Yet Dharavi is also a busy workplace. Thousands of small businesses, such as recycling, pottery and leather work, operate from homes and workshops. Any strategy has to deal with both the poor living conditions and the jobs that depend on the area.
1. Self-help schemes
A self-help scheme gives residents the tools to improve where they already live. Charities and community groups help families add concrete floors, brick walls, shared toilets and water pipes. This is often called upgrading. It is cheap, and it keeps families, neighbours and home-based businesses together. However, it is slow and small in scale. It does not solve overcrowding, and residents may still have no legal right to their land.
2. Slum clearance programmes
Slum clearance means bulldozing informal homes and moving the residents. Supporters say it frees land for roads, offices and new flats, and removes unsafe buildings. Critics point to the human cost. Communities are broken up, workshops are destroyed and families may be moved far from their jobs. People who cannot prove how long they have lived there may get no new home at all. Clearance can increase inequality if the poorest lose out.
3. Housing projects
Mumbai’s main housing approach is slum rehabilitation. Under this model, run by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority, a private developer rehouses eligible slum dwellers for free in new flats built on part of the land. In return, the developer can build extra flats on the rest of the land and sell them at market prices. The Dharavi Redevelopment Project plans to transform Dharavi in this way, replacing low-rise homes with tower blocks, new roads and services.
Benefits. Families get a permanent flat with a toilet, running water and electricity. They gain legal security, so they no longer fear eviction. The city gets better roads and drainage, and the scheme costs the government little because developers pay for it.
Problems. Flats can be small, and high-rise living does not suit workshops, kilns or recycling yards that need ground-floor space. Some residents end up paying maintenance fees they cannot afford. Families who are not eligible are left out. Developers make large profits, so critics argue the land’s value goes to the wealthy rather than to the residents.
4. Mass transit schemes
Mass transit helps people reach jobs without needing a car. Mumbai’s suburban railway is the backbone of the city, but its trains are badly overcrowded at rush hour. The first Mumbai Metro line opened in 2014, and more lines are being built. Faster, cheaper journeys link poorer suburbs to jobs in the centre, so people can live further out where housing costs less. Mass transit also cuts road congestion and air pollution. On the downside, building new lines causes disruption and can displace homes along the route, and fares may still be too high for the poorest.
In Mumbai you must know four strategy types: self-help upgrading of existing homes, slum clearance, housing projects such as slum rehabilitation in tower blocks, and mass transit such as the suburban railway and Metro. Each helps some groups and can harm others.
London: Creating Sustainable Urban Environments
London’s challenges are different. Most people have basic services, but the city has high housing costs, polluted air on busy roads and big gaps between rich and poor boroughs. The goal is a sustainable urban environment, one that balances social, economic and environmental needs.
BedZED eco-village
BedZED (the Beddington Zero Energy Development) in Sutton, south London, was completed in 2002. It was designed to show that low-energy city living is possible. Homes have thick insulation and solar panels, rooftop cowls bring in fresh air, and rainwater is collected. Residents are encouraged to share cars, walk and cycle. The site mixes homes for sale, shared ownership and social rent, so people on different incomes live side by side. Its weakness is scale: it is a small village, not a whole city.
The Olympic Park legacy
The 2012 Olympic Games were built on brownfield land in Stratford, east London, one of the city’s most deprived areas. After the Games the site became the Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park. The athletes’ village was turned into the East Village homes, including affordable housing. Former industrial land became parkland and wetlands, and sports venues were reused by the public. A large shopping centre and new transport links brought jobs to the area.
Yes. Derelict land was cleaned up and reused, green space was created in a crowded area, and new jobs and transport arrived in a deprived part of London.
Not fully. Critics argue the area has seen gentrification. Rising rents and house prices mean many new homes are out of reach for long-standing local families, so the benefits may go to newcomers rather than original residents.
Charging the car
London uses charges to cut traffic and pollution. The Congestion Charge, introduced in February 2003, makes drivers pay a daily fee to enter central London. The ULEZ began in central London in 2019 and was expanded across all London boroughs in 2023. Income is put back into public transport. Cleaner air especially helps people living beside main roads, who are often on lower incomes. However, some low-income drivers and small traders say they cannot afford newer vehicles or daily charges.
London’s sustainable strategies include BedZED (eco-homes in Sutton, 2002), the Olympic Park legacy (brownfield regeneration in Stratford after 2012) and vehicle charging (Congestion Charge from 2003, ULEZ from 2019, London-wide in 2023).
Comparing the Two Cities
Mumbai’s strategies tackle basic needs: shelter, sanitation and getting to work. London’s strategies tackle quality of life: clean air, energy use and affordable homes. Both cities share one lesson. A strategy that helps the city as a whole can still harm a particular group. Slum clearance can free land but cost families their jobs. Olympic regeneration can create parks but push up rents. Always ask who gains, who loses and whether inequality really falls.