Evidence for Climate Change & How Reliable It Is
What Evidence Is There for Climate Change?
The Earth’s climate has never stayed still. It has swung between freezing ice ages and warmer spells many times. Nobody was holding a thermometer for most of that time, so geographers act like detectives. They use clues left in ice, oceans, art and old writing. This lesson answers two questions. What pattern of change do these clues show? And how far can we trust each one?
The Quaternary Pattern
The Quaternary period covers roughly the last 2.6 million years. It is the period we live in now. Its climate has not been one long ice age. Instead it has switched back and forth. Cold glacial periods saw ice sheets spread across large parts of the land. Warmer interglacial periods saw the ice melt back. We are living in an interglacial today.
The Quaternary begins
Repeated cycles of glacials and interglacials start.
Oldest ice core record
Air trapped in Antarctic ice reaches back this far.
The last ice age ends
Ice sheets retreat and the current interglacial begins.
The Little Ice Age
A colder spell; the River Thames freezes and Frost Fairs are held on the ice.
Thermometer records
Direct measurements show a global warming trend, especially since about 1980.
Look at the shape of this pattern. Over millions of years, change is slow and cyclical. Ice builds up, then melts, then builds up again. Inside the current interglacial there are smaller wobbles, such as the Little Ice Age. What stands out about the most recent warming is its speed. It is unusually fast and it is global.
The Quaternary began about 2.6 million years ago. Its climate has swung between glacial and interglacial periods. The last ice age ended about 11,500 years ago, and recent warming is unusually fast.
How Do We Judge Evidence?
Most of our clues are proxy evidence. They do not measure temperature directly. Instead, they hint at it. To judge the reliability of any clue, ask four questions. How far back does it go? How precise is it? Does it show the whole world or just one place? Is it a direct measurement or an indirect hint? Keep these four tests in mind for every type of evidence below.
Ice Cores
Snow falls on Antarctica and Greenland every year and never fully melts. Over time it is squashed into layers of ice. Scientists drill long tubes of this ice, called ice cores. Tiny air bubbles are trapped in each layer. These bubbles show what the atmosphere was like when the snow fell, including how much carbon dioxide it held.
Strengths: ice cores give the longest record on this list, reaching back about 800,000 years. The gas in the bubbles is a real sample of the old atmosphere. Carbon dioxide levels in the cores track temperature closely, so they show the glacial and interglacial pattern clearly.
Limitations: cores only come from polar ice sheets, so they mainly describe conditions near the poles. Deep layers are squashed thin, which makes the oldest parts harder to date precisely. Drilling is also slow and expensive, so there are fewer cores than scientists would like.
Sea Ice Positions
Sea ice is frozen seawater floating on polar oceans. Its edge moves as the climate warms or cools. In the past, sailors and explorers recorded where they met the ice. Today, satellites photograph it from space. A shrinking area of sea ice is strong evidence of warming.
Strengths: modern satellite images are accurate and cover whole oceans, not just one spot. Changes are easy to see and compare from year to year. Limitations: the record is short. Older records depended on where ships happened to sail, so there are big gaps. Sea ice also changes naturally with the seasons and with winds, so one year alone proves little. A long trend is needed.
Global Temperature Data
Thermometers have been used for around 150 years. Readings from weather stations and ships around the world are combined into a global average. This data shows a warming trend, especially since about 1980.
Strengths: this is direct measurement, not a proxy. It is precise and comes from many places. Limitations: 150 years is a blink in the Quaternary. Early readings came from fewer places, mostly in richer countries, so some regions were missed. Stations have been moved or surrounded by growing towns, which can make readings warmer than the wider area.
Ice cores give the longest record, about 800,000 years, but mainly show the poles. Global temperature data is direct and precise but only covers around 150 years. Sea ice positions are clear from satellites but the long record has gaps.
Paintings and Diaries
Historical sources help with the last few hundred years. Paintings of Frost Fairs on the frozen River Thames in the 1600s show that winters were colder than today. This was during the Little Ice Age. Paintings can show snow, ice and frozen rivers in places where that rarely happens now.
Diaries and written records add detail. People noted harsh winters, floods and poor summers. Harvest records kept by monasteries show when crops did well or failed, which hints at the weather. These sources give a human, local picture of what living through a colder spell was like.
Paintings were made to look good or tell a story, not to record science. An artist might add extra snow for drama or paint from memory. A painting also shows only one place on one day. It cannot tell us the average temperature of a year, let alone the world.
Diaries are subjective. One writer’s ‘bitter winter’ might be another’s normal one. Writers recorded unusual weather, not ordinary days, so diaries can make the past seem more extreme than it was. They also mostly come from places where people could read and write, such as Europe.
No single source is perfect. Each one covers a different time span and a different area. Ice cores show the long Quaternary pattern. Paintings and diaries fill in recent centuries. Thermometers and satellites show the most recent change in detail.
When different sources agree, our confidence grows. This is called corroboration. For example, a painting of the frozen Thames is much stronger evidence when diaries and harvest records from the same years also describe cold weather. A strong geographer judges evidence by how well it fits with the rest.
Paintings and diaries show local, human evidence of colder spells such as the Little Ice Age. They are subjective and patchy, so they are most reliable when other sources agree with them.