StudyVault
Home Unit Overview Revision Techniques Previous Lesson Next Lesson

Back to Home

Page tint:
0:00 / 0:00

Natural Causes & the Enhanced Greenhouse Effect

The Big Question: Is Climate Change Natural?

This lesson tackles one enquiry question: is climate change a natural process? Earth’s climate has swung between ice ages and warmer spells many times during the Quaternary period. Those swings happened long before anyone burned coal or drove a car. So scientists have to ask a hard question. Is today’s warming just another natural swing, or are people now the main driver? To answer it, you need to know three natural theories — sunspots, volcanic eruptions and Milankovitch cycles. Then you weigh them against the human impact on the greenhouse effect.

Theory 1: Sunspots

Sunspots are dark patches that appear on the surface of the Sun. When there are lots of sunspots, the Sun is more active and gives out slightly more energy. When there are very few, it gives out slightly less. The number of sunspots rises and falls in cycles, so the energy reaching Earth changes a little over time.

Some scientists link a long spell with very few sunspots in the late 1600s to the Little Ice Age. This was a cold period when the River Thames froze and frost fairs were held on the ice. So sunspots can nudge the climate. However, the changes in the Sun’s energy are small compared with the warming we see today. That makes sunspots a weak explanation for modern climate change.

Theory 2: Volcanic Eruptions

Large eruptions blast ash and gases high into the atmosphere. One of these gases, sulphur dioxide, forms tiny droplets called aerosols. Aerosols reflect sunlight back into space before it reaches the ground. Less sunlight reaches the surface, so the planet cools.

The 1815 eruption of Tambora in Indonesia is the classic example. It cooled the planet so much that 1816 became known as the ‘year without a summer’. But the effect only lasts a few years. The aerosols gradually fall out of the atmosphere and the cooling fades. This means eruptions explain short, sharp cooling dips. They cannot explain a long, steady warming trend.

Key Fact

Volcanic eruptions cool the climate by releasing aerosols that reflect sunlight. The cooling lasts only a few years, so eruptions cannot explain long-term warming.

Theory 3: Milankovitch Cycles

Milankovitch cycles are slow, regular changes in the way Earth moves around the Sun. They alter how much sunlight reaches different parts of the Earth over tens of thousands of years. This theory explains the timing of the ice ages. When less sunlight reaches the far north in summer, snow and ice can build up year after year. When more sunlight arrives, the ice melts back and a warmer period begins.

Stretch. The shape of Earth’s path around the Sun changes slowly. Sometimes it is close to a circle and sometimes it is more oval. This changes how near Earth gets to the Sun at different times of year.

Tilt. The angle of Earth’s axis changes slowly. More tilt gives hotter summers and colder winters. Less tilt gives milder seasons, so summer snow is less likely to melt.

Wobble. Earth’s axis wobbles like a spinning top. Over time this changes which part of the year each hemisphere is closest to the Sun.

Key Fact

Milankovitch cycles work over tens of thousands of years and explain the timing of ice ages. They are far too slow to explain warming that has happened since the Industrial Revolution.

The Natural Greenhouse Effect

The natural greenhouse effect keeps our planet warm enough to live on. It depends on greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, methane and water vapour. These gases act like a blanket around the Earth. Without them, the Earth would average about −18°C. So the greenhouse effect itself is not the problem — it is essential.

First, sunlight passes through the atmosphere and warms the Earth’s surface. Second, the warm surface gives off heat as infrared. Third, greenhouse gases absorb this infrared. Fourth, they re-emit it in all directions, including back down towards the surface. This keeps the lower atmosphere warm. A common mistake is to say greenhouse gases block incoming sunlight. They do not — they trap the heat that Earth gives off.

The Enhanced Greenhouse Effect

The enhanced greenhouse effect is the extra warming caused by humans. Since the Industrial Revolution, people have added greenhouse gases to the atmosphere quickly. Burning fossil fuels for electricity, transport and industry releases carbon dioxide. Farming adds methane from cattle and rice paddies, and nitrous oxide from synthetic fertilisers. Deforestation removes trees that would otherwise absorb carbon dioxide. Adding more gases thickens the blanket, so more heat is trapped and temperatures rise.

The numbers are striking. Carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has risen from around 280 parts per million in 1750 to over 420 parts per million today. That is the highest level in 800,000 years. Methane and nitrous oxide exist in much smaller amounts, but they are powerful. Over a century, methane traps about 28 times more heat than carbon dioxide, and nitrous oxide nearly 300 times more. Even small increases in these gases matter.

Key Fact

Carbon dioxide has risen from about 280 ppm in 1750 to over 420 ppm today — the highest in 800,000 years. This extra gas strengthens the greenhouse effect and causes the enhanced greenhouse effect.

Weighing the Evidence

The case for natural causes. Climate has always changed. Milankovitch cycles explain why ice ages came and went throughout the Quaternary. Sunspot activity has been linked to the Little Ice Age. Tambora showed that one eruption can cool the whole planet. So it is fair to say natural processes are real and powerful.

The case for human causes. Each natural cause has a weakness when used to explain today’s warming. Milankovitch cycles are too slow. Volcanic eruptions cause cooling, and only for a few years. Changes in solar energy from sunspots are too small. Meanwhile, greenhouse gases have risen sharply since the Industrial Revolution, and carbon dioxide is at its highest level in 800,000 years. It is the speed of today’s change that stands out. Most scientists agree that human emissions are now the dominant cause of warming.

Key Fact

Climate change can be natural, but natural causes are too slow, too short-lived or too small to explain today’s rapid warming. Most scientists agree humans are now the main cause.

A strong judgement avoids saying ‘it is all natural’ or ‘it is all human’. Try this frame: “Climate change has been a natural process in the past, as Milankovitch cycles show. However, today’s change is mainly human, because natural causes cannot explain how fast greenhouse gases and temperatures are rising.” Then back it up with one figure, such as the rise in carbon dioxide from 280 to over 420 parts per million.

Exam question

AI feedback
This is a guide, not an exam mark. If your teacher marks it differently, go with your teacher.

Next lesson Back to unit
Explainer