StudyVault
Home Unit Overview Revision Techniques Previous Lesson Next Lesson

Back to Home

Page tint:
0:00 / 0:00

Presenting, Analysing & Evaluating Fieldwork

This lesson covers the general skills, terminology and exam expectations for presenting, analysing and evaluating fieldwork that apply to every student. The specific sites, data and methods your class used will be different. For the questions about your own fieldwork, use your teacher’s notes and the data you collected on the day.

After the Data: The Second Half of an Enquiry

Collecting data is only half of a fieldwork enquiry. The specification is clear that the investigative process goes beyond data collection. You also need to present your results, analyse them, draw conclusions and then reflect critically on the whole process. This lesson covers those four stages.

These skills are tested in the fieldwork section of both the physical and the human geography paper. Some questions ask about your own fieldwork. Others give you an unfamiliar context with someone else’s data. The same thinking works for both.

Stage 1: Processing and Presenting Data

Raw data in a notebook is hard to read. Processing means turning it into something useful, such as totals, averages or percentages. Presenting means showing it visually, using maps, graphs and diagrams. The golden rule is simple: choose the method that fits the type of data.

  • Line graph — change over time or along a distance, such as river width at sites moving downstream.
  • Scatter graph — the relationship between two variables, such as distance from a town centre and pedestrian count.
  • Bar graph — comparing separate categories, such as land use types.
  • Pie chart — proportions of a whole, such as the share of questionnaire answers.
  • Cross-section — the shape of something, such as a river channel or a beach profile.
  • Rose chart — directional data, such as wind direction.
  • Dispersion graph — how spread out a set of values is.

Maps add the ‘where’. A choropleth map shades areas to show a pattern, such as environmental quality scores in different streets. Proportional symbols drawn on a base map show values at exact locations, so bigger circles mean bigger numbers. Flow line maps show movement, and annotated sketch maps or photographs help explain what you saw.

Key Fact

The presentation method must match the data. Scatter graphs show relationships between two variables, line graphs show change over distance or time, and maps show spatial patterns.

Stage 2: Analysing and Explaining Data

Analysis has two parts. First, describe what the data shows: the overall pattern or trend, with figures quoted as evidence. Second, explain why that pattern exists, using the geography you have learned. The specification says you should use knowledge of relevant case studies and theories. For a river study, that might mean linking results to the erosion and deposition processes from Distinctive Landscapes. For an urban study, it might mean linking to your city case studies from Urban Futures.

Statistics help you describe data precisely. The mean, median and mode are measures of central tendency, which show a typical value. The range and the interquartile range show spread. A small spread suggests results are consistent, while a large spread suggests a lot of variation.

Imagine a student records nine practice values, already in order: 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 12, 15, 21.

The median is the middle value, which is 8. The range is the highest minus the lowest: 21 minus 2 gives 19. The mean is the total, 84, divided by 9, which is about 9.3.

For the interquartile range, find the middle of each half. The lower half (2, 4, 5, 7) gives a lower quartile of 4.5. The upper half (10, 12, 15, 21) gives an upper quartile of 13.5. The interquartile range is 13.5 minus 4.5, which is 9. Notice that the mean is higher than the median because the value of 21 pulls it up. That is why the median is often more useful when one result is unusually large.

When you compare two variables, you are working with bivariate data. Plot it on a scatter graph and sketch a line of best fit. If the line slopes upwards, the relationship is positive. If it slopes downwards, it is negative. If the points are scattered with no clear line, there may be no relationship. The line also lets you interpolate, which means estimating values between your sites, or extrapolate, which means predicting beyond them. Extrapolation is riskier because you have no data there.

Look out for an anomaly. Do not ignore it. Suggest a reason for it, such as a measuring error or a real local feature, because explaining anomalies shows strong analysis.

Stage 3: Drawing Evidenced Conclusions

A conclusion answers your enquiry question or says whether your hypothesis was supported. It should be short and direct, but it must be backed by evidence from your results. Avoid vague claims like “the data proves it”. Instead, quote specific figures and explain what they mean.

Key Fact

A strong conclusion has four parts: a clear claim answering the question, evidence from the data with figures, an explanation using geographical knowledge, and an honest note of its limits.

Partial conclusions are fine. If your hypothesis was true at most sites but not all of them, say so. Saying a hypothesis was “partly supported” and explaining why is more convincing than pretending every result fitted.

Stage 4: Reflecting Critically

Critical reflection means judging your own enquiry honestly. The specification names four things to reflect on: the data, the methods used, the conclusions drawn and the knowledge gained. This stage needs judgement, not just description.

A key idea is reliability. Would you get the same results if you repeated the fieldwork? Accuracy is a different idea: how close your measurements are to the true value. Both depend on your sample size, your procedures and the equipment you used.

Data: Was the sample large enough? Were there gaps or anomalies? Was the data collected on one day only, so it might not be typical?

Methods: Did everyone follow the same procedure? Was any data subjective, such as an environmental quality score that depends on personal opinion? Was a control group or comparison site used?

Conclusions: How confident can you be? Could another factor explain the pattern? Would the conclusion still hold at a different time or place?

Knowledge gained: What did the enquiry teach you about the geography of the place, and how does it link to theory or your case studies?

Key Fact

Every weakness you identify should come with a reason and an improvement. Saying “the sample was small” earns little; explaining why that matters and how to fix it shows real evaluation.

Spotting Weak Presentations

You also need to identify weaknesses in how data has been presented. In unfamiliar contexts, look for graphs with unlabelled axes, missing units, uneven scales, or the wrong graph type for the data. Be suspicious of conclusions based on very few results. Then suggest an improvement, such as a different graph or a clearer scale. This skill matters because skills questions can be based on unseen resources, including data collected by someone else.

Exam question

AI feedback
This is a guide, not an exam mark. If your teacher marks it differently, go with your teacher.

Next lesson Back to unit
Explainer