Case Study: Food Security in the UK
This lesson uses the UK as its example of a country trying to achieve food security. Your teacher may have chosen a different country, or given you specific statistics to learn. In the exam, use the country and figures from your own class notes. This lesson shows you how to structure that case study and how to judge each strategy.
How Can Countries Ensure Their Food Security?
This lesson answers one enquiry question: how can a country make sure its people have enough food? A country has food security when everyone can get enough safe, healthy food, all of the time. Your case study must cover three things. First, statistics on food consumption and availability over time. Second, one local attempt to improve food security. Third, one past and one present attempt at a national scale.
Why Study the UK?
The UK is a wealthy advanced country (AC). You might expect it to be completely food secure. It is not that simple. The UK imports a large share of its food, especially fruit and vegetables that do not grow well in its climate. Some households also cannot afford a healthy diet, even when supermarket shelves are full. So the UK shows that food security is about access as well as supply.
Food security has two sides. A country can have plenty of food available nationally, yet some people still lack access because they cannot afford it. The UK has both a supply issue (imports) and an access issue (poverty).
Food Statistics Over Time
The spec asks you to investigate statistics on food consumption and availability over time. One key measure is food self-sufficiency. This is how much of its own food a country grows or produces. During and after the Second World War, the UK worked hard to raise self-sufficiency. Since then, it has come to rely more on imports, as global trade made food from abroad cheaper and available all year round.
Consumption has changed too. UK diets now include far more processed foods, imported fruit and foods from many cultures than they did in the mid-twentieth century. Average calorie intake in the UK is high by world standards. However, average figures hide inequality. Some people eat more than they need, while others skip meals because money is tight.
When you meet a table or line graph of food data, describe the overall trend first. Is it rising, falling or fluctuating? Then quote the start and end figures with units. Then pick out any anomaly, such as a sudden dip in a crisis year. Finally, calculate a percentage change if the question allows it.
Always ask what the statistic leaves out. A national average calorie figure tells you about supply. It does not tell you who goes hungry. That gap is a weakness in the data, and pointing it out shows you are thinking critically about the evidence.
A Local Attempt: Food Banks
A food bank collects donated food and hands out emergency parcels to people in crisis. Many UK food banks belong to the Trussell Trust network. Others are run by churches, mosques, schools and community groups. People are often referred by a doctor, social worker or advice centre. Use of food banks rose sharply during the 2010s, and demand grew again during the cost-of-living crisis that began in 2022.
How successful are food banks? They work fast. They help people today, and they are run by volunteers who know their local area. Many also offer advice on debt, benefits and energy bills. But they rely on donations, which can fall when everyone is struggling. Critics also say food banks treat the symptom, hunger, rather than the cause, which is low income. Rising use can be read two ways: the scheme reaches people, but food insecurity is getting worse.
Food banks give quick, local help to people in crisis, but they depend on donations and do not tackle the root cause of food insecurity in the UK: low household income.
A Past National Attempt: Wartime and Post-War Farming
During the Second World War, enemy submarines attacked ships bringing food to Britain. The government brought in rationing in 1940 so that scarce food was shared fairly. The Dig for Victory campaign urged people to turn gardens, parks and allotments into vegetable plots. After the war, the Agriculture Act 1947 gave farmers guaranteed prices and markets. This encouraged intensive farming, using tractors, fertilisers and pesticides to grow much more food on the same land. Rationing finally ended in 1954.
Economically and socially, the strategy worked. Home production rose, farmers had secure incomes, and the UK became much less dependent on imports. Rationing also meant poorer families got a fairer share than before.
Environmentally, the costs were high. Hedgerows were removed to make bigger fields for machines. Chemical use harmed wildlife and polluted rivers. So the strategy was effective for food supply but not fully sustainable. This links to the spec’s wider question of how sustainable food production methods are.
A Present National Attempt: Global Food Trade
Today, the UK relies heavily on global food trade. It imports food from many countries so shoppers can buy almost anything, at any time of year, at competitive prices. Buying from many suppliers spreads risk. If one country has a poor harvest, the UK can buy from another.
But trade has weaknesses. In 2020, panic buying during the Covid-19 pandemic left some supermarket shelves empty and showed how fragile supply chains can be. In 2022, the war in Ukraine pushed up world prices of wheat and fertiliser, which raised food prices in UK shops. Trade also creates long transport journeys, adding to carbon emissions. So trade keeps food available, but it can make food less affordable when global shocks hit.
The UK’s past strategy (post-war intensive farming) boosted home production but damaged the environment. Its present strategy (global food trade) gives choice and spreads risk, but leaves the UK exposed to shocks such as the 2020 pandemic and the 2022 war in Ukraine.
Comparing the Strategies
To judge effectiveness, use three tests: environmental, economic and social sustainability. The post-war drive scores well on supply and farm incomes, but poorly on the environment. Global trade scores well on choice and price in normal times, but poorly on resilience. Food banks score well on helping individuals quickly, but they cannot fix national supply or low pay. A strong answer weighs these against each other and reaches a clear judgement.