Managing Antarctica: Local Tourism Rules & the Antarctic Treaty
Is There More to Polar Environments Than Ice?
This lesson answers one enquiry question: how are humans seeking a sustainable solution for Antarctica? You need two case studies. The first is a small-scale example, here the rules that control tourist landings. The second is a global example, here the Antarctic Treaty. You should be able to describe each one and judge how well it works.
Why Antarctica Needs Managing
Antarctica is a very fragile place. It is extremely cold, so plants such as mosses and lichens grow very slowly. Damage from one footprint on a moss bed can last for years. Food chains are short, and many animals, including penguins, seals and whales, depend on krill. Human activities such as tourism, fishing, whaling and mineral exploitation can upset this balance. Sustainable management tries to let people use Antarctica while keeping it healthy for the future.
Antarctica is managed at two scales. Small-scale rules control what visitors do at each landing site. Global agreements, led by the Antarctic Treaty, control what whole countries are allowed to do across the continent.
Small-Scale Example: Sustainable Tourism
Most tourists visit the Antarctic Peninsula by ship during the short southern summer. Many ships sail from Ushuaia in Argentina. Tour companies set up the IAATO in 1991. Its members agree to follow guidelines that limit the damage visitors cause on land.
Key rules for landings include:
- Ships carrying more than 500 passengers are not allowed to land anyone ashore.
- No more than 100 people can be ashore at one site at the same time.
- Visitors must keep their distance from wildlife, usually at least 5 metres, and never feed or touch animals.
- Boots and clothing are cleaned before landing to stop non-native species being carried in.
IAATO landing rules limit numbers at two levels: no landings from ships with more than 500 passengers, and no more than 100 people ashore at one site at once. This spreads visitors out and reduces trampling and disturbance.
Strengths: tour companies want Antarctica to stay wild, because that is what customers pay to see. This gives them a reason to follow the rules. Trained guides go ashore with every group and enforce the distances. Visitors often return home as supporters of conservation.
Weaknesses: the guidelines are mainly self-regulation by the industry, so they rely on operators choosing to follow them. Ships still burn fuel and risk accidents. In 2007 the cruise ship MS Explorer struck ice and sank near the South Shetland Islands; everyone on board was rescued, but it showed the danger of oil spills. A ban on using heavy fuel oil in Antarctic waters came into force in 2011 to reduce this risk.
Your teacher may have used whaling instead of tourism. The International Whaling Commission stopped commercial whaling with a moratorium from 1986. In 1994 it created the Southern Ocean Whale Sanctuary around Antarctica. Japan kept hunting whales there, calling it scientific research. In 2014 the International Court of Justice ruled that this programme was not for scientific purposes. Japan left the commission in 2019 and stopped hunting in the Southern Ocean.
Global Example: The Antarctic Treaty
The Antarctic Treaty was signed in Washington in 1959 by 12 countries, including the UK. It came into force in 1961. Today more than 50 countries have joined it. Seven countries, including the UK, Argentina and Chile, claim parts of Antarctica. Some claims overlap, which could have caused conflict.
The Treaty’s main rules are:
- Antarctica is used for peaceful purposes only, so military bases and weapons testing are banned.
- Nuclear explosions and dumping radioactive waste are banned.
- Scientists from all countries are free to carry out research and must share their results.
- Territorial claims are frozen: no new claims can be made while the Treaty is in force.
The Treaty was strengthened by the Madrid Protocol, signed in 1991 and in force from 1998. It names Antarctica a natural reserve devoted to peace and science. It bans all mineral resource activity except scientific research. Every activity needs an environmental impact assessment first, and waste must be removed from the continent.
The Antarctic Treaty (1959) keeps Antarctica peaceful and open to science. The Madrid Protocol (1991, in force 1998) bans mining and requires environmental impact assessments for all activities.
Successes: there has been no war in Antarctica and no commercial mining. Countries with competing claims cooperate on science. Research stations have cleaned up old waste. Membership has grown from 12 to more than 50 countries.
Limitations: decisions are made by agreement, which can be slow. There is no Antarctic police force, so enforcement depends on each country. Claims are only frozen, not settled. The Madrid Protocol can be reviewed from 2048, so the mining ban is not guaranteed forever. Fishing, including krill fishing, is managed by a separate body, and pressure on krill is growing.
Comparing the Two Scales
The two examples work together. The global Treaty sets the big rules for whole countries, such as no mining and no military use. Small-scale tourism rules deal with what happens on the ground, one landing at a time. A strong answer explains that global rules give long-term protection, while local rules reduce day-to-day damage. Each would be weaker without the other.